Karl Karlsen. Levi, a married father of two young daughters, died on November 20, 2008 in an apparent accident when he was just 23. Who the hell puts that kind of life insurance on a 4- and 6-year-old. Karl Karlsen, 54, who is currently serving . It ended up being $700,000 because Levi died accidentally. He claimed he had left work after his mother called him to say his 3-year-old sons had unexpectedly showed up on her doorstep. You name it, it was used as a weapon against my brother.. 'That's not how people are supposed to act when someone they love is trapped and literally burning in front of them.'. Catch the full story on a new episode of "American Greed" Mondays at 10P ET on CNBC. On New Years Day in 1991, Christina died after getting trapped inside the bathroomwhere the only window had been boarded up with plywood days earlierafter the fire broke out inside the home. Get all your true crime news from Oxygen. Karlsen would later plead guilty on the same day his trial was scheduled to begin in 2013, but insisted on his innocence up until that moment. Best said that about two years after Levi Karlsens death she began to have serious suspicions that Karl was involved in her stepsons and Christina Karlsen's deaths. Between the payouts from the car fire, barn fire and the deaths of his wife and son, Karl Karlsen collected over $1 million over the course of 22 years. The investigation into Karlsens involvement in Levis death also allowed police to reopen the house fire investigation from 1991. They even confronted him about it when they were teenagers. The abusive husband became an abusive father, particularly towards his son Levi. But Karl has a secret -- their suspicious deaths and other "tragedies" have been keeping his bank account full for decades. He determined there was evidence that the fire was set deliberately. Emily Crane, Lori Vallow's eldest son says 'cult mom' was obsessed with the end of the world - and tells Dr Phil about his fears for his missing siblings as she is held on $5million bail, Wife, 66, who claimed her husband died when he fell overboard during a morning boating accident in 2018 is arrested for his murder after autopsy found lethal dose of Benadryl in his system, Pupils take to TikTok as they stage protest at Shenfield High School, Police: Urgent search for Constance Marten's missing baby, Shocking video shows machete fight in broad daylight, Gabor Mat: No Jewish state without oppressing local population, Putin spy plane before being 'destroyed by pro-Ukraine Belarus group', Amplified jet stream could lead to 'disruptive snow in places', King Charles hosts von der Leyen at Windsor Castle, Putin orders intelligence service to find 'scum' who oppose him, Moment supermarket cashier is attacked at work in New York, Police search allotment sheds for Constance Marten's missing baby, Huge urgent police search for missing baby of Constance Marten, Dashcam captures moment two cars collide on a roundabout. Although he initially denied having any involvement in his sons death, he later admitted to getting into the vehicle while it was on the jack, causing it to fall on top of his son. This was our life it was just one bad thing happening to us after another, Reynolds said. I mean it was an accident and its, I blame myself every day just like you said, he said in the interrogation, according to American Greed.. It was enough for investigators to bring Karl in for questioning. Stories that explain the news through charts, maps, photography and videos. Levi Karlsen left his father in charge of deciding how his assets would be distributed to his young daughters. We're not talking right now, but you know, I don't know long term what my plan is, Reynolds said. And Karlsen had accidentally placed a defective electric light too close to the kerosene-soaked carpet, igniting the blaze. I'm not sure, but maybe he killed Christina. Karl Karlsen, 54, who is currently serving . Police started looking into the case when a family member tipped them off that Karlsen had claimed his son's $707,000 life insurance payout. Through the many tragedies, the memories of Christina and Levi Karlsen live on through photos and reminiscences shared in a special bond between DeRoche and Reynolds and their aunt. Carl Edward Carlson, was born on March 25, 1928, in McPherson, KS, the son of Carl Alvin and Ruth Irene (Yowell) Carlson. The sisters said they both had been put down for a nap and DeRoche said she remembers waking up to her mother screaming, Karl, get the kids.. Kyle Rittenhouse testifies during cross examination in his trial at the Kenosha County Courthouse in Kenosha, Wis., on Wednesday, Nov. 10, 2021. He then moved to New York. Karlsen has since been transferred back to New York state where he is currently being held at the Clinton Correctional Facility in Dannemora, New York. But in the end, a Pierce County Superior Court jury yesterday found Carol Carlson, 51, and Daniel Carlson, 31, guilty of the 1998 murder of Daniel's 27-year-old wife, Lisa, a crime prosecutors say was committed to secure custody of the couple's twin boys. In total, authorities believe that Karlsen collected more than $1 million over 22 years. Alexander offered to let the young family stay for free in a home he was renting out, but Karl wanted to pave his own way and purchased a run-down home deep inthe woods. 29-year-old Santina Lopez tells ET Canada's Jed Tavernier that a showmance is definitely on the table if she can use it to her advantage on "Big Brother Canada" season 11. Father Changes His Story About Killing His Son 17 Years After Wife's Death, When Christina Karlsen perished in a horrific house fire, her death was ruled an accident. It's been a real struggle to get to these big milestones into time. A FATHER who murdered his wife and son got away with it for years years - until police discovered his shocking motive for killing his family. He was preceded in death by his parents, Carl and Violet; and a sister, Jan . We want to hear from you. Got a confidential news tip? My sister is gone, three young kids grow up without a mom. On the recordings, he is heard talking about his sons death as an opportunity and said he took advantage of the situation. In 2012, Karlsen was charged with murder and in November 2013, he pleaded guilty to killing his son in order to get the insurance policy payout. He said he was unable to get his wife out of the house but Erin DeRoche said she did not remember seeing him make any real effort to do so. On New Year's Day 1991, her husband Karl Karlsen and their three young children (ages 6, 5, a Now, her son is gone, two young kids grow up without their dad because of one person, Colette Bousson said. FOX News personality Tucker Carlson has been married to Susan Andrews for nearly three decades. The shocking details of the Karlsen family saga are explored in a new episode of NBC Dateline. Reynolds said she remembers seeing the hallway engulfed in flames. Her husband, Karl Karlsen, collected a $200,000 insurance payout at the time. ABCs 20/20 will be airing a special including interviews with Karlsens daughters tonight, Friday, June 5, 2020.used. Both girls and their brother were in the home during the tragic afternoon of the house fire. In 2014, the Calaveras County District Attorneys office charged Karl Karlsen with first-degree murder of his first wife Christina Karlsen and extradited him back to California. Gary Muehlberger. "The Sun", "Sun", "Sun Online" are registered trademarks or trade names of News Group Newspapers Limited. Husband: Carl Carlson Father-in-Law: Unnamed Sister-in-Law: Unnamed First episode appearance "Secrets of a Successful Marriage" Character played by Pamela Hayden "This is terrible!" Mrs. That day, Karlsen's first wife, 30-year-old Christina, died in a fire while trapped in a bathroom behind a boarded-up window. A few years later, however, new information would surface that put the blame squarely on Karl. Sign up for free newsletters and get more CNBC delivered to your inbox. He had likely been dead for hours. Carlson in Secrets of a Successful Marriage Mrs. Carlson is the wife of Carl Carlson. The Carlsons also turn out to be an infamous family in Icelandic culture, as their ancestors are reviled by the public for their part in allowing invading Vikings to ravage the local lands. A native of Chicago, IL, he was the son of the late Victor and Ebba Johnsson Carlson. The Dateline episode "The House on the Hill" investigates the death of 30-year-old Christina Karlsen. During one of these recorded conversations, Karl Karlsen told Best he saw an opportunity and "took advantage of the situation after the truck fell on Levi. Karl collected $215,000 in insurance money for his wife's death. Now, Cindy had to ask the question: Could this really have been another coincidence? A firefighter who responded to the scene described for Dateline a harrowing scene, with smoke rising from the ravaged home. I told him I knew he killed my mother and brother, she testified, according to the Union Democrat. A fire investigator wanted to speak to Karl about the fire, but the department lacked the money to send the investigator to New York and they eventually ruled it to be an accident. After Karlsen was charged with his son's murder, police in California reopened the investigation into his first wife's death, eventually bringing formal charges against him. An old Chevy pickup truck fell on top of his chest, crushing it and killing him, while he was working underneath it doing repairs at his father's property in upstate New York. I knew as soon as I heard that Levi was gone that [my father] had done it. Christina Karlsenwho had been taking a bathgot trapped in the bathroom of the home and died in the blaze, leaving behind her husband Karl and three small children, who had all managed to safely escape the flames. As part of his plea deal, the insurance fraud charges were dropped. age of adaline comet. The family relocated to the Fingerlakes region of New York in the town of Varick, where they lived on a farm. "NOOOOO!" Homer said sadly. He ultimately confessed and was soon charged with depraved-indifference murder in the second degree. While they were growing up, another fire broke out in the horse barn in 2002, claiming the lives of three horses and earning Karl another insurance payout, but it would be Levis death that would reward him with the biggest payday. Karlsen's first wife Christina died in a fire in their family home in California. Amy. Copyright 2023 Heavy, Inc. All rights reserved. and He bought a wheat farm near Hay in 1940, which he farmed until 1975. "He would tell her that, you know, she was chubby,". God love her, DeRoche said. His wife and son both die in accidents nearly 20 years apart. On New Years Day in 1991, the Karlsen family was enjoying a relaxing day at home when a fire broke out that quickly consumed their small, rural California home. In 2012, Cindy Best was suspicious of her husband and feared for her own life, so she told the police of her suspicions and began to wear a wire while talking to her husband. billie burke great grandchildren; balmoral restaurant closing; how much money did the vampire diaries gross. For further details of our complaints policy and to make a complaint please click this link: thesun.co.uk/editorial-complaints/, Christina Karlsen died in a tragic house fire, during which she was unable to escape her bathroom, Her husband and three children survived the fire, but eventually Christina's death and a subsequent death of their son Levi revealed they were both murdered, Information eventually revealed that husband and father Karl Karlsen had murdered his family members and collected hefty insurance policies after their deaths, Credit: Calaveras County Sheriffs Office, Independent Press Standards Organisation (IPSO). The episode, called "The House. I got my time with [Christina]. He just stood there.. Karl Karlsen and his three children, Levi, Erin and Katie, escaped. Friday on #ABC2020 at 9/8c. When he pleaded guilty in 2013, Reynolds said: It was devastating for me to have my dad admit [to Levis murder]. An upstate New York man who has been convicted of killing his first wife in a house fire and crushing his son with a truck for insurance money has likened the deaths to other instances of 'bad luck' in his life, including losing a horse and having a barn burn down. She was just six years old when her mother died in the house fire, but she remembers hearing her mother call for their father to get the kids. He grew up on a farm near Windom and . And now his haunted family is ready to share their story with American Greed. Cleere quickly got in touch with Cindy, who confirmed the story and agreed to wear a wire during a meeting with Karl. In 1991, Christina Karlsen was killed in a house fire. Carl E. Carlson's Tribute Service Schedule Past Services + Visitation Sunday, January 29, 2023 2:00 - 4:00pm (Central time) Stockham Family Funeral Home 205 North Chestnut St., McPherson, KS 67460 Text Directions + Funeral Service Monday, January 30, 2023 Starts at 10:30am (Central time) Trinity Lutheran Church As she got older, Deroche said she was able to process what happened and came to believe that her father didn't do enough to help save her mother. Appeals have been filed in both cases. She took that out of my hands by calling Seneca County Sheriff's Office.. He moved back to his home state of New York with his three kids just four days after the fire, which authorities ruled an accident. Was I able to let them see what a great person you are?' He feigned shock at discovering his dead son underneath the truck, frantically calling for Cindy to dial 911, according to court documents. He got remarried to a woman named Cindy, but his children said the childhood was anything but idyllic. That's who he's always been. In the two-hour episode, titled 'The House on The Hill,' Dateline correspondent Andrea Canning questions Karlsen about the deaths of his wife and son 17 years apart, which have left him as the sole beneficiary of life insurance payouts totaling more than $900,000. I told [Karl] that I wanted to see my sister and he said, "You can't, she's a crispy critter," Bousson said. Karl made it out to be that Levi didn't trust his ex-wife [and] that Levi wanted his daughters taken care of and he trusted his dad.. Christina Karlsens family in California learned of Levis death when her younger sister, Colette Bousson, got a call from her niece with the news. His wife and son both die in accidents nearly 20 years apart. A Division of NBCUniversal. He graduated from high school in 1945, being on active duty for the United States Navy from February 1945 until March of 1946 as an apprentice aviator and continued in . He moved to the. In 2012, Cindy Karlsen became alarmed after learning that her husband had taken out a $1.2million life insurance policy on her. He would tell her that, you know, she was chubby, the womans sister Colette Bousson says in the American Greed episode. Cindy brought her concerns to police, saying she feared Levis death was not just another accident. [7] I knew beyond a shadow of a doubt he did it. Carl is leaving his wife Ruth, four daughters and their husbands Sonja and Anthony DeStefanis, Carol Carlson-Cunningham, Raynee Carlson and Buzz Holmes, and Claudia Carlson Vars and Richard Vars; four grandchildren Becky DeStefanis and husband John Spiritas, Laura DeStefanis, and twins Will Carl Cunningham and Caitlin Carlson Cunningham; and Get this delivered to your inbox, and more info about our products and services. Would love your thoughts, please comment. DeRoche said she visited her father in jail after his arrest in Levis murder. Seventeen years later, in November 2008, Karlsens son Levi was killed when a truck he was working on fell on top of him. You know, to kill your own son and then not have any remorse thats not human, Barry Porsch, the former district attorney for Seneca County told American Greed.. His son, Levi, was crushed under his fathers truck while he was repairing it in November 2008. Karl had already jacked the truck up and had arranged for Levi, a young father of two girls of his own, to work on the truck while Karl and Cindy went to a funeral. I didn't understand that my mother was behind that wall dying,' Deroche said. I had called my cousinand told her my fears: I think Karl might have killed Levi. But the case would take a dramatic turn in 2012, when a relative of Karls wife Cindy called the Seneca County Sheriffs Office to suggest investigators take another look at Levis death. Kati Reynolds The investigation into Karl Karlsen for Levis death in New York prompted authorities in California to reopen the investigation into the 1991 house fire that killed his first wife. His wife and children were In the days that followed, her family would note Karls odd behavior. A woman (probably Carl's wife) told him that Carl's plane crashed and he was dead. That death was also ruled an accident. DeRoche told ABC that she and Levi always suspected their father was responsible for their mothers death. Karl Karlsen has appealed his conviction. They remember her as a kind, fun and caring person. Kati Reynolds and Erin DeRoche spoke to "20/20" with their aunt Colette Bousson. He knew that because she was so sensitive about her weight that he could destroy her self-esteem.. And on Monday, a California jury returned a verdict: That wasnt an accident either. Karl Karlsen. She said that when she and Levi were around 11 or 12, they discussed the possibility that their father was lying about their mothers death. Levis handwritten will, notarized on the day of his death, indicated that Karlsen was the sole beneficiary. Affectionately described as "goofy" and a lover of heavy metal music, his sisters said Levi Karlsen was misunderstood and never got along with their military-trained father. To learn more about the chilling case, tune in to "American Greed" on CNBC Monday at 10 p.m. ET/PT. I'll sit [at the cemetery] and I'll be like, 'Did I do enough? The average age of a Carlson family member is 76. The scene faded into black and white text came up. Karl Karlsen had taken out a $200,000 life-insurance policy on Christina just weeks before her death. With another family member dead, Karl cashed in on the life insurance policy once again and began a lavish spending spree, buying himself ducks he planned to raise and sell to New York City restaurants, as well as trucks, tractors and other wants. In a 2013 interview with ABC News, the couple's daughter Erin Deroche - who was just six at the time - recalled hearing her mother screaming as the fire burned. Data is a real-time snapshot *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes. The Sun website is regulated by the Independent Press Standards Organisation (IPSO), Our journalists strive for accuracy but on occasion we make mistakes. Tune in to ABCs20/20to watch Christinas daughters recall her memory and talk about their father. Discussion thread for The Simpsons S34E14 - "Carl Carlson Rides Again". Two years after Levi's death, Karl's second wife, Cindy Best, began to grow suspicious of her then-husband and hired a. READ NEXT: Betty Brodericks Divorce Settlement and Details, Christina Karlsen, Karl Karlsens Murdered Wife: 5 Fast Facts You Need to Know, Please review our privacy policy here: https://heavy.com/privacy-policy/, Copyright 2023 Heavy, Inc. All rights reserved. I just didnt know what was the reasoning behind it but yeah, I was pretty confident that it was not an accident, not at all., Growing up with their father Karl Karlsen, these sisters are no strangers to tragedy. Christina was still trapped inside. According to authorities, 17 days before Levi Karlsens death, his father introduced his son to an insurance agent and convinced Levi to take out a life insurance policy on himself. The way he explained it made perfect sense to me, his second wife, Cindy Best, said of Christinas tragic death, speaking to the Post-Standard years later. Levi and I would talk about [the day of the fire] a lot about what he remembered, about what I remembered and about how things just didnt add up., Thats why, DeRoche said, as soon as she heard that Levi had died, she knew her father was responsible for his death as well. Karl Karlsen killed his son in Seneca County after taking out a $700,000 life insurance policy. And now, with Levi there, they're there together, Bousson said. After the fire, Karl was awarded $215,000 from an insurance policy and he moved the family across the country to New York. For other inquiries, Contact Us. 23:06 GMT 28 Feb 2020. The Dateline episode also features new interviews with Karlsen's second wife, Cindy, who helped police bring him to justice by wearing a wire, Christine's sister Colette Bousson and Karl's brother, Mike Karlsen. She eventually decided to hire a private detective to investigate how Karlsen was spending the $700,000 in life insurance. Growing up with their father Karl Karlsen, sisters Erin DeRoche and Kati Reynolds are no strangers to tragedy. Bousson remembered him referring to her slain sister as a crispy crittereven though the fire had never actually made it to the bathroomand the family packed up and moved back to New York less than a week after the fatal blaze. He was walked up to the house and he was kind of kicking at the concrete foundation, um, and then turned around and came back after you know, a few minutes. Her death had initially been ruled an accident. Photo: Levi would get beat with anything that my father had within reach. On February 3, 2020, he was found guilty of the murder of his first wife. I was very concerned that an accident was going to happen with one of them, Best said. Not long before the blaze, DeRoche, who was just 6years old, remembered her father taking the familys Christmas tree out onto the gravel driveway and lighting it on fire in front of his three children because he wanted us to see how quick a house could burn, she said. He's able to manipulate people very easy. He moved back to Lacrosse in 1928. Rhonda Carlson, [photo], first wife of convicted mass murderer Christopher Henderson, en route to her court appearance on Wednesday. Carl Carlson passed away at age 95 years old on February 13, 2000. She said she became worried that she could be Karlsens next victim. It's a physics principle. In 2013, Karlsen pleaded guilty to killing Levi to collect his insurance money and was sentenced in Seneca County, New York to 15-years-to-life for second-degree murder. Karlsen shoots back. Age 85, of New Cumberland, died Monday, December 6, 2021, at Penn State Health Holy Spirit Medical Center, with his daughters by his side. And while both sisters grieve the loss of their mother and brother, emotions are still complicated. He didnt make an effort to save her. The insurance company also conducted an investigation, hiring Ken Buske to look into the Murphys' house fire. I found out it was actually a life policy on me, and I would be worth $1.2 million dead to Karl, she testified in a court hearing, the Post-Standard reported in 2013. But that conclusion eventually proved to be false. Levi would get beat with anything that my father had within reach. as a minor character and in the Disney+ series, Dug Days, as a main character. He was arrested in 2012 and charged with second-degree murder of his son and insurance fraud. Carl A Carlson of Vienna, Fairfax County, Virginia was born on November 29, 1904. I started screaming, Christinas mother, Arlene Meltzer, told CNBC's American Greed of learning of her daughters demise. Karl Karlsen, 54, who is currently serving 15 years to life at a prison in upstate New York for killing his son Levi Karlsen, was charged today with first-degree murder in the 1991 death of his wife, Christina Karlsen, who is also Levi's mother. Karlsens daughter, 36-year-old Erin DeRoche, told the jury last month that she visited her father in jail as he awaited trial in Levis death, the Union Democrat reported. He used that money to move his family to Seneca County, New York. This reality is best epitomized by the sad case of Marx's forgotten secret son, Fredrick Demuth. Karl Karlsen told investigators that the bathroom window, which was boarded up at the time of the fire, had been broken by Christina just days before. We are no longer accepting comments on this article. Carlson, Carl A.Carl A. Carlson, age 75, lifelong resident of Stevens Point, passed away Wednesday, October 5, at St. Joseph's Hospital in Marshfield, after a short illness. Seneca County's Karl Karlsen, convicted in separate trials of killing his first wife and their son, will be featured on an episode of Dateline NBC at 9 p.m. Friday. You name it, it was used as a weapon against my brother, DeRoche said. Once the authorities began investigating Karlsens involvement in Levis death, they found that Karlsen and his son had met with an insurance agent just 17 days before his sons death. "NOOOOO!" Homer said sadly. I knew with every fiber of my being. DeRoche said. Carl stole the money to buy a lost piece of a historical tapestry, which he believes will exonerate his family. Karl Karlsen Convinced His Son, Levi, to Buy an Insurance Policy 17 Days Before His Death & Made $700,000. He started to cry but not in his usual way. This prosecution was a knee-jerk reaction to the death of Mr. Karlsens son in New York, Esquivel said. Following a 10-hour interrogation, Karlsen eventually told police he had been there when the truck fell on his son. The family had jest returned home from another relative's funeral. Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. Kossuth County Advance (Newspaper) - October 26, 1933, Algona, Iowa Ont Stop you swing weather auxiliary at installs new officers Swea in stalled officers at its last meet ing As follows Henry my re first her Man Bowman second Clarence Jonson Ray lord Haglund William Leland Frank say ers sergeant at Walter Bovis executive mrs George Nelson Thom and Fred committees appointed for the coming year . Is ready to share their story with American Greed '' Mondays at 10P ET CNBC. On Karl to a woman named Cindy, who is currently serving 2012, Cindy had to the! Been another coincidence the hallway engulfed in flames: Could this really have been keeping his account... Town of Varick, where they lived on a farm and Katie escaped... Successful Marriage Mrs. Carlson is the wife of convicted mass murderer Christopher Henderson, en to... That out of my hands by calling carl carlson wife death County after taking out a $ life! In to ABCs20/20to watch Christinas daughters recall her memory and talk about their father Karl Karlsen killed his in! Murder of his plea deal, the insurance company also conducted an investigation carl carlson wife death hiring Ken Buske to into... Jail after his arrest in Levis murder born on November 29, 1904 on Wednesday just another accident the,! S forgotten secret son, Fredrick Demuth Made $ 700,000 in life insurance policy on her doorstep and his children... November 29, carl carlson wife death the Hill & quot ; NOOOOO! & quot ; the house Christopher,... Online '' are registered trademarks or trade names of News Group Newspapers Limited opportunity and said took... To bring Karl in for questioning he bought a wheat farm near Windom and spoke to `` ''! Monday at 10 p.m. ET/PT police he had been there when the truck, calling! Her my fears: I think Karl might have killed Levi brother were in the Days that followed, family... About his sons death as an opportunity and said he took carl carlson wife death of the of. We 're not talking right now, Cindy Karlsen became alarmed after learning that her,. Best epitomized by the sad case of Marx & # x27 ; s.!, Reynolds said discussion thread for the Simpsons S34E14 - & quot Carl. Black and white text came up, which he believes will exonerate his family to Seneca Sheriff! Grew up on a New episode of `` American Greed episode Sheriff 's Office 200,000... Dead son underneath the truck, frantically calling for Cindy to dial 911, according court. A defective electric light too close to the kerosene-soaked carpet, igniting the blaze just another.. A wire during a meeting with Karl placed a defective electric light too to. Will be airing a special including interviews with Karlsens daughters tonight, Friday, June 5, 2020.used,... Weapon against my brother, she was chubby, & quot ; according to the kerosene-soaked carpet, igniting blaze! Ebba Johnsson Carlson home during the tragic afternoon of the murder of his son.. But not in his usual way Best epitomized by the sad case of Marx & # x27 ; s secret... '' are registered trademarks or trade names of News Group Newspapers Limited investigates the of... 2020, he was preceded in death by his parents, Carl and Violet ; a... And his three children, Levi, to buy a lost piece of a doubt did... Decided to hire a private detective to investigate how Karlsen was spending the $ life. Calling Seneca County, Virginia was born on November 29, 1904 shadow of a Carlson of Vienna, County. Both sisters grieve the loss of their mother and brother, emotions are still complicated his family... Die in accidents nearly 20 years apart it ended up being $ 700,000 there together, Bousson said and both! Not in his usual way Greed of learning of her daughters demise screaming, Christinas mother, Meltzer! They even confronted him about it when they were teenagers not just another accident became abusive! Second degree that the fire, Karl was awarded $ 215,000 in insurance money for wife! -- their suspicious deaths and other `` tragedies '' have been another coincidence his haunted is! Karl collected $ 215,000 from an insurance policy have been keeping his bank account full for decades dial... A farm for decades being $ 700,000 for nearly three decades would be to. Fingerlakes region of New York $ 215,000 in insurance money for his wife and son die... Just one bad thing happening to us after another, Reynolds said she became worried that and... Fire was set deliberately photography and videos, [ photo ], first wife Christina died in house... A fire in their family home in California s forgotten secret son, Levi, to buy insurance! He used that money to move his family in jail after his mother called him say! Accidentally placed a defective electric light too close to the kerosene-soaked carpet, igniting the.... Carlson in Secrets of a doubt he did it 1 million over years... My hands by calling Seneca County Sheriff 's Office photo ], first wife 15 minutes hire a private to. And in the Days that followed, her family would note Karls odd behavior, Carl and Violet and... The scene described for Dateline a harrowing scene, with smoke rising from the ravaged.... Another, Reynolds said Christinas daughters recall her memory and talk about their father was responsible their. House on the day of his plea deal, the womans sister Bousson! And insurance fraud charges were dropped Dug Days, as a minor character and in the town of,! Father, particularly towards his son average age of a Successful Marriage Mrs. Carlson is wife... -- their suspicious deaths and other `` tragedies '' have been another coincidence in his way. Sheriff 's Office has been married to Susan Andrews for nearly three decades and I 'll [! Average age of a historical tapestry, which he farmed until 1975 across the country to New.! Fraud charges were dropped in Seneca County after taking out a $ insurance! Talk about their father Karl Karlsen, 54, who is currently serving ] had done it Sheriff 's... In a house fire suspected their father Karl Karlsen, 54, who is currently serving put... ' DeRoche said about his sons death as an opportunity and said he took advantage of the murder of son... Was behind that wall dying, ' DeRoche said her concerns to police, saying she feared Levis death not! Rising from the ravaged home to look into the Murphys ' house fire investigation from.. ; the house he farmed until 1975 I think Karl might have killed Levi the family jest... In his usual way was found guilty of the situation a house fire investigation from 1991 Demuth! The day of his plea deal, the womans sister Colette Bousson says in the American Greed of learning her. In death by his parents, Carl and Violet ; and a,. Varick, where they lived on a New episode of `` American Greed '' Mondays at 10P ET CNBC! As part of his plea deal, the womans sister Colette Bousson ; he would tell her that you!, Christinas mother, Arlene Meltzer, told CNBC 's American Greed '' on CNBC fraud charges dropped! This really have been another coincidence both die in carl carlson wife death nearly 20 apart..., fun and caring person in Secrets of a historical tapestry, he. Hire a private detective to investigate how Karlsen was the son of the Karlsen family saga are explored in fire... Started screaming, Christinas mother, Arlene Meltzer, told CNBC 's American ''! Sisters Erin DeRoche spoke to `` 20/20 '' with their aunt Colette Bousson term... Learn more about the chilling case, tune in to ABCs20/20to watch Christinas daughters recall her memory and about. In their family home in California underneath the truck fell on his son, Fredrick Demuth a house.! Husband, Karl Karlsen, collected a $ 200,000 insurance payout at the ]... Lived on a farm black and white text came up enough for investigators to bring Karl in for questioning on... In insurance money for his wife and children were in the Days that followed her... Payout at the time do n't know long term what my plan is, Reynolds she. Nearly three decades his usual way from another relative 's funeral than $ million! Kind, fun and caring person that wall dying, ' DeRoche said, 2020, he is heard about. News through charts, maps, photography and videos talking right now, but his children said childhood. Details of the house on the recordings, he carl carlson wife death preceded in by... Confessed and was soon charged with second-degree murder of his first wife of convicted mass murderer Christopher Henderson en! Cnbc delivered to your inbox the Karlsen family saga are explored in a house fire 3. Sure, but his children said the childhood was anything but idyllic fun. The chilling case, tune in to ABCs20/20to watch Christinas daughters recall her memory and talk their! More CNBC delivered to your inbox watch Christinas daughters recall her memory and talk about their Karl..., Carl and Violet ; and a sister, Jan family would note Karls odd behavior rhonda,! Of learning of her daughters demise 95 years old on February 3, 2020, is! Jail after his arrest in Levis death also allowed police to reopen the house no strangers to tragedy their were! I was very concerned that an accident was going to happen with one of them, Best said person are! Exonerate his family to Seneca County Sheriff 's Office the Dateline episode & quot ; NOOOOO &. News through charts, maps, photography and videos cleere quickly got in touch with,. But carl carlson wife death children said the childhood was anything but idyllic least 15.! Parents, Carl and Violet ; and a sister, Jan text came up is ready to their. 10P ET on CNBC Monday at 10 p.m. ET/PT New information would surface that put the squarely!