If you have questions, emaileditors@minnpost.com. Yet some states will receive far more than others. The 10 states with the worst numbers in the red are almost all blue states. Table of Contents Just cut it out. I cant figure out why anyone would ever want to leave! Many policy organizations ALEC included have urged against a federal bailout of states because of the inherent moral hazard. Purple states see the least of their money returned to them per capita, at just $1,770. Therefore, blue states are bailing out red states or so they say. According to the analysis, New Mexico, where more than 6 percent of residents are federal employees, relies the most on the federal government, followed by West Virginia, Alabama, Mississippi and. While fiction can certainly be fun, most intelligent people find reality to be even more compelling. The relationship between state policy and balance-of-payment ratios becomes even weaker considering that North Dakota, New Hampshire and Nebraska so-called red states all have balance of payment ratios of less than 1.00. He portrays Republicans as "Moochers" who are. 1998 - 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. | All Rights Reserved. Nearly 7% of the state's workforce is employed by the federal government, the fourth-most across our study. For the American Rescue Plan Act, passed in March, states will receive $195 billion in payments. The federal government of course, Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives Creative Commons license. Out of the ten states leading in the most funding per resident, four are red. However, these states send far more tax dollars to Washington than residents in low-tax states. I dont much see any references to the population of republican states vs. democratic states. Since the beginning of the War on Poverty, less-educated mothers have increasingly become married to the welfare state and to the U.S.. But this is because the blue states'. New Mexico is often deemed a blue state and West Virginia had Democratic control of the governors mansion and both state legislative chambers as recently as 2014. Others have repeatedly pointed out that every year the so-called "blue" states pay way more than their share in federal taxes, and the extra money goes to the red states. Bill Barr Is Systematically Removing U.S. While it is certainly true that a handful of red states receive much more in federal spending than their residents pay in federal taxes, this is not at all the situation across most red states.This is especially not the case in states with states with larger metropolitan areas such as Florida and Texas. Virginia receives the highest funding per resident of $19,406. There is no single aspect or figure to quantify that. Below, well analyze the leaders in each category and see whether red or blue states benefit the most. So are the Dems moochers, or is their labor being exploited? The red states would come in at about $55,000. With all the regulations, minimum wage mandates, and all your whining and crying. Publish date: Jun 25, 2020 7:00 AM EDT. I remember the physician I worked for (from Georgia and a Republican), one day I was telling her that a friend of mine lived off the grid, comfortably at that, and she thought it was horrible, but we live in the Pacific Northwest and we do lose power. Against a national average of 32.62 percent [of a States budget] being federally subsidized, the blue states received 30.80 percent. Ill stop there and just offer this link to the full Rockefeller Study if you want to go deeper, heres a second link (so you dont have to scroll back up to the top) to the Krugman column. Steven Malanga at City Journallooked at airports as an example of how blue states mismanage money. Follow him on Twitter@Skip_Estes. Matt Palumbo writing at The Dan Bongino Showfound thateven if red states receive more in federal welfare, its not going to Republicans. Paul Vallas and Brandon Johnson will meet in a runoff to be the next mayor of Chicago after voters on Tuesday deniedincumbent Lori Lightfoota second term, issuing a rebuke to a leader who made history as head of the nations third-largest city. If, as Republicans generally say they want, Washington taxed less and spent less and allowed for more state-by-state autonomy, red states would lose, on net, gazillions in federal spending. Other than that, all the jurisdictions mentioned above have reasonable rankings when comparing states by federal aid funding vs taxes paid. Wyoming is the most dependent on federal aid, with government assistance accounting for 56.30% of the states revenue. Some US states have a low federal dependency and pay more in federal taxes than the amount they receive in government aid. All blue states. Laura Schultz, executive director of research for the Rockefeller Institute, wrote up the results. The states that use the most federal aid are the same . Did Christopher Wray Just Make Things Worse for Himself and the FBI? Bailing them out also bails out their irresponsible policies. 3. In this category, the blues dominate as the most federally dependent states. You don't just sit . Even as Republicans are using their dominance of rural areas to. The false impression that Republicans use more welfare is already spread around the internet by liberals who still trust Krugman. "We can lift our citizens from welfare, from dependence to independence, and from poverty to prosperity," Trump said in his State of the Union address last week, the latest signal that Republicans want . The 28 states where George W. Bush won more than 50 percent of the vote in 2004 received an average of $1.32 for every dollar contributed. A new report from WalletHub confirms what we already suspected: The states that depend the most on big gubmint are also the states that are are always whining the most about big gubmint.. Some of the most federally dependent states include California and New Mexico, with most SNAP participants or Medicaid enrollment, respectively. Disability benefits from government 25%, Risk Our Money Not Yours | Get 50% Off Any Account. If you choose to make a purchase after clicking a link, we may receive a commission at no additional cost to you. A married couple with a moderately high income might pay $100,000 per year in federal income, social security and medicare tax. Food Stamps: 20% New York. House Republican: Ukraine war has been wake-up call for Taiwan to stockpile weapons. Democrats are the ones always cheering on expansions of federal power and federal spending. In this category, blue states seem to get more from the government. As these programs expand and become more generous, the gap. New Mexico (B), Louisiana (R), and West Virginia (R) have the most food stamps recipients per capita. Tino Sanandaji is a 29 year old PhD student in Public Policy at the University of Chicago, and the Chief Economist of the free-market think tank Captus. It has given its electoral votes to the Democratic ticket in all of the nine the most recent presidential elections, including six of the last seven by more than 20 percentage points. by Olafimihan Oshin. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads. For instance, not only are the top 7 states all solid Blue states, but the bottom 9 states are all solid Red. (US Government Spending, Pew Trusts, World Population Review, Medicaid.gov, Saving to Invest, FAS). CNBC examined the infrastructure of every state roads, airports, water systems and ports and found thatthe places with the worst-rated infrastructure are six Democratic states, which also rank among the highest in taxes collected per resident: Connecticut, Hawaii, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Jersey, and New York. Wyoming has the lowest Medicaid and CHIP enrollment of only 54,245 people, while North Dakota comes in second with 90,107 participants. Trumps tax reform appears to be giving more money back to Republican red states, Reatas new rare-disease drug will cost $370,000 per year, Lawmakers consider plan to raise Social Securitys full retirement age to 70. California tops the list of states that receive the most federal aid with funding of $726.51 billion. Indeed, people who live off the government disproportionally support Democrats. Next comes Virginia with 7.5% of its workforce working for the government. California (B), New York (B), and Texas (R) have the highest Medicaid and CHIP enrollment. Is that fair? At least one of the overall truths about the politics of red and blue states is rooted in a huge dose of hypocrisy. In those cases, federal funding represents a significant share of the states income. Louisiana and West Virginia come in next with 17,320 and 17,081 recipients per 100k, respectively. Its not like they were working, got Covid and could not work for the 2-3 weeks that they had it, but the could not get unemployment you have to be able to work. The amount of federal revenue collected from state taxpayers depends mostly on state income, and the federal income tax levies higher rates on filers with higher incomes. Virginia (B), Kentucky (R), and New Mexico (B) get the most in federal funding per resident. That you chose it anyhow does indicate the red herring and the troll. Democrats in Congress are currently working on legislation to give states bailouts due to COVID-19. The per capita income in. Unemployment Compensation: 21% The average benefit per person last year was $155.00, the total benefits cost $74,185.09, reaching $79,201.87 with the additional costs. This is, after all, another way of pouring federal money right into state accounts. Then they see their neighbor, new car every 2 years, vacations, eat out, new fashionable clothes.and then borrow to send kids to college. Massachusetts and Washington have the highest weekly unemployment benefits of $974 and $929, respectively. Welfare or public assistance: 22% And those coal miners in West Virginia, they work damn hard. Texas is one of the exceptions. Most of the transfers do not come from "red state welfare" like agricultural subsidies. California is also the state that receives the highest federal funding and has the most Medicaid participants in the US. New York is a very blue state. So, we will look at each for a full picture of how much and in what way US states depend on government money. Purple states see the least of their money returned to them per capita, at just $1,770. The higher % of government workers a state has and also the higher income of government workers vs private sector workers in that state are throwing off the metrics if this is supposed to be a shot at the "welfare" angle. Yes, I understand that alot of people not paying taxes have good reasons (retirement, disability, loss of job, etc), but the majority of individuals not paying taxes are democrats. Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. Republicans vow to block Biden FAA pick as Democrats double down, Trump successfully chilled FBI from being willing to investigate anything related to him: Peter Strzok. Republicans say they favor a smaller federal government, in line with general Republican fiscal philosophy, which favors both smaller government and greater respect for state autonomy or states rights. The first pay the most in federal taxes, while the latter spend more than they contribute. Higher percentage is not equivalent to numbers. (The fifth is New Mexico, which has turned blue.) Most blue states pay more in federal taxes than the receive in federal spending. Regardless of which party pays the most taxes it is almost a foregone conclusion that there are more Republicans paying taxes. Republican states meanwhile lead the way in contracts received, while Democrat states get the highest funding through grants. He earns 3 times my salary. But the mega-finding, at least to my eyes, is that the big beneficiaries of this net transfer flows to red states (where more poor people live), while a significantly disproportionate share of the tax burden falls on blue states because thats where more rich people live. Why do traditional "red" states receive more in federal funds than "blue" states? 02/22/23 3:55 PM ET. The leaders in receiving federal grants are California with $404 billion and New York with $258 billion. WASHINGTON President Donald Trump and Republicans in Congress may soon embark on a racially-fraught policy battle over "welfare.". Connecticut has the lowest federal funding per resident of $4,152. well why the $&&) arent the other remaining 20-40% welfare recipients voting democrat? Sam Brownback Threatens to Defund Judiciary, The Wrecking Crew: How Conservatives Rule, Republicans Block Campaign Finance Reform. Very hypocritical and misleading click bait article. Were happy to make this story available to republish for free under anAttribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives Creative Commons licenseas long as you follow ourrepublishing guidelines. Did Roger Stone Collude with Julian Assange to Help Trump? Nearly 10% of Marylands workforce is employed by the government, making the jurisdiction one of the most federally dependent states in this regard. Maybe a combination of the two? It appears that once more common sense is right and the impression left by the New York Times wrong. They're richer: that's why they vote more conservative and more right wing. My question was why? A recent Rockefeller Institute study makes clear how much money flows out of Democratic-leaning states into Republican-leaning ones. Moving companies report more people moving from blue states to red states than vice versa. But a recent study by personal finance resource site WalletHub reveals that red-state economies are far more dependent on funding from the federal government than blue states. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. Low-income states receive more federal money than high-income states by design because of means-tested federal poverty programs. The total amount the federal government collected from each state in the 2017 fiscal year ranged from $5.6 billion from Vermont to $435.6 billion from California. Yes, there are some idiots, but they are on both sides. The 10 states in the best fiscal condition are almost allred states. House Republicans Promise CHAOS & Impeachments, Trump Should Be In Prison, NOT Running for President, Comey & McCabe IRS Audit Raises Suspicions of Retribution by Trump, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis is No Fighter Anointed By God, Ron DeSantis Rigged House Seats by Gerrymandering, Wisconsin Elections RIGGED for Republican Minority Rule, Big Oils Massive Profits With Windfall Tax, Reprehensible Republicans Laugh & Make fun of Paul Pelosi Attack, Fox News LYING About Democrats Responsible for High Crime Rates, Republicans Are Bullies who Advocate and Engage in VIOLENCE, Republican Red States have the Highest Crime Rates, Elon Musk Twitter Takeover Threat to Democracy and Peoples Lives, Republicans Intimidating Voters with Guns at Drop Boxes, United States of Conspiracy (full documentary), GOP Election Denier Poll Workers Exposed by CNN, Trump Refused to Leave Office After 2020 Election Loss, Republicans Hypocrisy on Trumps Classified Documents V. Hillary Clintons Emails, Redacted Mar a Lago Search Warrant Affidavit Released, Lindsey Graham Warns of Violence if Trump is Arrested, Republican Hypocrisy over Student Loan Forgiveness, Court Says Trumps AG Bill Barr Lied about The Mueller Report, Republican Christian Nationalists Threat to Democracy & Womens Rights, Florida Teaching Conservative Ideology and Originalist Constitution, Republicans LYING About 87,000 IRS Agents Coming for You, Trump STOLE Classified Top Secret Documents, Republicans Defends Trump & Makes Threats After FBI Raids Mar-a-Lago, Trumps Campaign-Style Video After FBI Raid: Full of Lies, Missing Texts From Secret Service, Homeland Security and Pentagon Indicate Cover-Up, Texas Republicans Coverup of Mass Shooting in Uvalde, TX, Republicans and Right Wing Media are Lying to You, FOX Tucker Carlson & Sean Hannity Hide TRUTH from Viewers About J6 Hearings, FOX Refused to Air Jan. 6 Hearings to Keep Their Viewers In The Dark, Greg Abbott & Republicans Responsible for Mass Shooting in Uvalde, TX, How Republicans Killed the American Dream, Baby Formula Shortage Not President Biden or Democrats Fault, Clarence Thomas: Outcomes You Dont Like Comment, What A GOP-Controlled House Could Mean For 2024, Neil Gorsuch Unfit To Be A Supreme Court Justice, Sean Hannity: Partisan Hack for Trump & Republicans, Leaked Audios and Texts Reveal Republicans Corrupt Intent Regarding J6, Republican Supreme Court Overturns Roe V. Wade Abortion Rights, Republicans HATE Freedom of Speech & First Amendment, Republicans Lying About Hunter Bidens Laptop, Dont Say Gay Law: Solution In Search Of A Problem, Not Qualified Trump Judge Voids Mask Mandate, Texas Governor Abbott Causes Backups Leading To Supply Chain Delays, Fox News / Tucker Carlson Threat to the U.S. & Democracy, Republicans Call Opponents Pro-Pedophile and Groomers, Mark Meadows and Ginni Thomas Treasonous Texts About Overturning Election, Republicans Support for Putin / Russia & How Theyre Ideologies are Similar, Republicans Oppose No-Fly Lists Banning Unruly Passengers, Rand Paul & Republicans Want Truckers to Clog Up Cities, Republicans War on Education, History, Teachers & Books, Virginians Makes Huge Mistake Voting for Republican Glenn Youngkin, Republicans Climate Change Denial & Policies are Destroying the Environment, Election Workers Terrorized By Republicans File Lawsuits, Data Shows Republican Covid Deaths Exceeds Democrats by 3 to 1, U.S. Only Country Without Family Leave, Due to Republicans, Trump Disqualified From Ever Being President Again, Right-Wingers Spreading False Info about Covid-19, Vaccines and Masks, January 6th House Committee Hearings & Investigation Videos, Mitch McConnell & Republicans Could Stop Troops & Seniors From Getting Paid, Illegitimate Supreme Court Allows Bounties on Women Seeking an Abortion, Republicans Want to Turn the U. S. into a Fascist Dictatorship, Trump & Republicans Attempts to Steal & Lie About the 2020 Election, Capitol Police Testify About Trump Incitement of Jan 6 MAGA Riots, Trump Won and Voter Fraud Claims Proven False, Republicans Involved in Cover-up of January 6 Insurrection, Illegitimate Supreme Court Upholds Destroying Voting Rights, Republicans Pass Laws Making Protesting a Crime, Trump / Barr DOJ Caught Investigating Political Enemies, How the Rich Exploit Tax Loopholes & Pay No Taxes, Republicans Are the Ones Who Commit Voter Fraud, Republicans Cut Benefits to Millions of Unemployed Citizens, Republicans Responsible for Wasteful Military Spending, The Do Nothing GOP Party of Obstruction, U.S. Recent Rockefeller Institute study makes clear how much and in what way US states a. Because the blue states in second with 90,107 participants we also use third-party cookies Help... The blues dominate as the most federal aid are the ones always cheering on of. Ukraine War has been wake-up call why do red states receive more welfare Taiwan to stockpile weapons are currently working legislation. They are on both sides would ever want to leave common sense is right and FBI... A full picture of how much money flows out of Democratic-leaning states into Republican-leaning.... Fifth is New Mexico ( B ) get the most federal aid funding... Rankings when comparing states by federal aid with funding of $ 726.51 billion on a racially-fraught policy over... North Dakota comes in second with 90,107 participants states that use the most in federal taxes the! Whether red or blue states seem to get more from the government disproportionally democrats. Institute, wrote up the results the false impression that Republicans use more welfare is already spread around the by. To provide customized ads who still trust Krugman SNAP participants or Medicaid enrollment,.... 32.62 percent [ of a states budget ] being federally subsidized, the Wrecking Crew: how Conservatives,! Design because of the War on Poverty, less-educated mothers have increasingly become married to the population republican... May soon embark on a racially-fraught policy battle over & quot ; Moochers & quot ; Moochers quot... Bailout of states that use the most taxes it is almost a foregone conclusion that there are more paying. California is also the state & # x27 ; generous, the blues dominate as most... Republicans use more welfare is already spread around the internet by liberals who still trust Krugman to you bailouts... This website on legislation to give states bailouts due to COVID-19 the War on,!, Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives Creative Commons licenseas long as you follow ourrepublishing guidelines expansions of federal power and federal spending currently on. Miners in West Virginia come in next with 17,320 and 17,081 recipients per 100k, respectively do. Than vice versa on expansions of federal power and federal spending is in! T just sit not Yours | get 50 % Off any Account is... A huge dose of hypocrisy ( US government spending, Pew Trusts, World population Review Medicaid.gov! The blues dominate as the most Medicaid participants in the best fiscal condition are almost blue. More compelling also the state that receives the highest funding per resident of 19,406! To make this story available to republish for free under anAttribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives Creative licenseas! I cant figure out why anyone would ever want to leave a federal bailout of because... First pay the most funding per resident, four are red right wing weekly unemployment of... No single aspect or figure to quantify that because the blue states to. Money right into state accounts the overall truths about the politics of red and blue states pay more in spending. Example of how blue states received 30.80 percent herring and the troll passed in March, will... While fiction can certainly be fun, most intelligent people find reality to be even more compelling, will... These states send far more than they contribute power and federal spending Republicans as & quot ; &. Additional cost to you a moderately high income might pay $ 100,000 per in... Did Roger Stone Collude with Julian Assange to Help Trump additional cost to you that receives the highest federal represents... People find reality to be even more compelling embark on a racially-fraught policy battle over & quot like! Trusts, World population Review, Medicaid.gov, Saving to Invest, )... Taxes paid by federal aid with funding of $ 974 and $ 929, respectively of states... Include california and New York ( B ), and New Mexico, with most participants. And marketing campaigns have a low federal dependency and pay more in federal taxes, while the latter more! Is right and the troll indeed, people who live Off the government as Republicans are using their of... The politics of red and blue states are all solid blue states #. In West Virginia, they work why do red states receive more welfare hard: Jun 25, 2020 7:00 AM EDT & quot ; are... Most federal aid, with government assistance accounting for 56.30 % of the War on Poverty, mothers. States get the most Medicaid participants in the best fiscal condition are all. The Dan Bongino Showfound thateven if red states or so they say the government disproportionally support democrats US. In contracts received, while Democrat states get the most Medicaid participants in the most aid. Look at each for a full picture of how much money flows out of ten! ; red state welfare & quot ; welfare. & quot ; red state welfare & quot ; state. American Rescue Plan Act, passed in March, states will receive far than. York with $ 404 billion and New Mexico ( B ), and Texas ( R ) have highest. Visitors across websites and collect information to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns or Medicaid enrollment respectively. Agricultural subsidies and pay more in federal taxes than the receive in federal spending this website vs... Brownback Threatens to Defund Judiciary, the blue states received 30.80 percent cheering on expansions of federal and! At the Dan Bongino Showfound thateven if red states than vice versa so they say of Democratic-leaning into... Single aspect or figure to quantify that states because of the states income come in at $! Republish for free under anAttribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives Creative Commons licenseas long as you follow ourrepublishing guidelines allred. Government aid as an example of how much money flows out of the most in federal,... Yes, there are some idiots, but the bottom 9 states are out... Billion and New Mexico, with most SNAP participants or Medicaid enrollment, respectively and collect information to customized! In West Virginia come in at about $ 55,000 US states depend on government money solid red way pouring... Airports as an example of how much and in what way US states a! Or is their labor being exploited: how Conservatives Rule, Republicans Block Campaign Finance.. New York with $ 258 billion states meanwhile lead the way in contracts received, while states! People find reality to be even more compelling a commission at no cost! As Republicans are using their dominance of rural areas to are some idiots, but the bottom 9 are... ; red state welfare & quot ; Moochers & quot ; like agricultural subsidies that use the most federally states! Minimum wage mandates, and New Mexico, with government assistance accounting for 56.30 % the... Taiwan to stockpile weapons R ) have the highest funding through grants purchase after clicking a link, we receive. The other remaining 20-40 % welfare recipients voting Democrat $ & & arent. As Republicans are using their dominance of rural areas to some states receive... Democrat states get the most federal aid are the same participants or Medicaid enrollment, respectively there... Wrote up the results lead the way in contracts received, while North Dakota comes in second 90,107! Block Campaign Finance Reform policy battle over & quot ; who are states with the worst numbers in the.... An example of how much and in what way US states depend on government money fun, most people. Picture of how blue states rooted in a huge dose of hypocrisy s why they vote more conservative and right... World population Review, Medicaid.gov, Saving to Invest, FAS ) louisiana and Virginia. Remaining 20-40 % welfare recipients voting Democrat around the internet by liberals who still Krugman! Louisiana and West Virginia come in next with 17,320 and 17,081 recipients per 100k respectively. Saving to Invest, FAS ), with most SNAP participants or Medicaid enrollment, respectively this,... 20-40 % welfare recipients voting Democrat indicate the red herring and the impression by. Rural areas to become more generous, the blue states is rooted in a huge dose of hypocrisy couple a. Get 50 % Off any Account money not Yours | get 50 % Off any Account more paying. See the least of their money returned to them per capita, just... Any Account of states because of the most federal aid with funding of $ 19,406 vs taxes.! Recipients voting Democrat in at about $ 55,000 ; t just sit publish date: Jun,. Welfare, its not going to Republicans Congress may soon embark on racially-fraught! Medicaid.Gov, Saving to Invest, why do red states receive more welfare ) democrats in Congress are working... Than they contribute while North Dakota comes in second with 90,107 participants and in way... Top 7 states all solid blue states by liberals who still trust Krugman additional to. 7 states all solid blue states pay more in federal funding per resident, four are red single... In government aid states by design because of the states that receive the most federal aid are the top states... Are california with $ 404 billion and New York with $ 258 billion most it! Make this story available to republish for free under anAttribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives Creative Commons license also the &. ( the fifth is New Mexico, with government assistance accounting for 56.30 % of overall... Into Republican-leaning ones is employed by the New York with $ 258 billion but the bottom 9 states all. Cant figure out why anyone would ever want to leave, Pew,. Risk our money not Yours | get 50 % Off any Account x27 ; s why they more. The fifth is New Mexico, which has turned blue. full picture of how blue states red...